The Top 11 Indestructible Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

No one likes to give their pup a toy only to find that, within mere minutes, it’s been ripped to shreds. As you pick up stuffing from the lawn, you may wonder if it’s worth buying your dog a replacement toy. You may even be tempted to buy them so-called “indestructible” dog toys.

If you’ve got a heavy chewer on your hands, then be realistic when buying them new chew toys. Just like there’s no such thing as a truly hypoallergenic dog breed, no dog toy is truly 100% indestructible. Fortunately, a select few toys can stand up to the most aggressive chewers. Some rare toys even come with a lifetime guarantee.

Regardless of the breed, gender‌ or size, any dog can be a repeat toy-destroyer. With the most indestructible dog toys, your playful pet can get the mental stimulation they need without costing you a fortune on replacement toys (or your favorite pair of heels). So, if you need a new chew toy to offer up as tribute, try one of the plush toys, KONG toys, and chew toys below.

What is an aggressive chewer?

Most dogs like to chew. It’s a natural instinct that kicks in at an early age and can be a comfort for teething pups. But some dogs chew more than others. These aggressive chewers will tear through almost any toy, shoes, clothing, furniture, and household objects they get their teeth on.

If you’re worried about your dog’s chewing habits, check in with your vet or an animal behavioral trainer. There may be an underlying cause that can be treated, such as dental pain, anxiety, or boredom.

What makes a good dog toy?

Your dog may be happy with the stick they discovered on your morning walk or an old tennis ball from your garage. However, all good dogs deserve good toys made just for them. 

According to Richard Lovejoy, a dog trainer based out of Brooklyn, NY, indestructible dog chew toys are essential to your dog’s health and are also more sustainable. “It’s important to be considerate even beyond the scope of the dog’s health. It’s always good to think sustainably.” The best dog toys might be more expensive, but since they last longer, you can reduce waste and eliminate the cost of replacing toys. Lovejoy encourages dog owners to “be as responsible as you can in the arenas that you can be responsible.” 

When shopping for “indestructible” toys, here are some qualities to look for:

Versatility

You use a ball to play fetch, a jute rope to play tug-of-war‌, and a bone for chewing. But what if you could find a toy that serves multiple purposes? A lot of interactive toys give your dog ‌multiple forms of play. This reduces boredom and keeps your dog on their best behavior. For added enrichment, look for toys that dispense dry dog treats, such as puzzle balls.

Health and dental benefits

Dog toys offer tons of health benefits. Chewing on toys can relieve stress, reduce anxiety, fulfill dogs’ instinctual needs, and promote dental health. Plus, this behavior is perfect for teething puppies while they wait for their adult teeth. Chewing on the right kind of rubber can also remove plaque buildup and stimulate gums, which improves the overall health of your dog’s mouth.

Materials

Look for toys made from 100% natural, food-grade rubber or fabric. This will stop your dog from accidentally ingesting harmful materials and chemicals. You want to make sure that if your dog breaks off a few chunks, they’ll be able to pass them without complications.

What are the best indestructible dog toys?

So, which toys should you buy for your heavy chewer? Here’s Pumpkin’s ultimate guide to the best indestructible dog toys for aggressive chewers. Keep in mind that we’re being hyperbolic with the term “indestructible.” No toy is 100% destruction-proof in all circumstances, but some of them come pretty close.

1. Woof Pupsicle Refillable Treat Dispenser

The treat-dispensing Pupsicle chew toy from pet care brand Woof comes personally recommended by Pumpkin team members. One of our designers says their dog Jonny has barely been able to make a dent in this toy.

We also appreciate the clever design. The screw-top can be removed so you can easily clean this toy between uses, and Woof makes Pupsicle Refill Pops perfectly sized for the toy (peanut butter works, too). This heavy-duty chew toy was made with a reinforced body and drool slots, and you can even pop it in the dishwasher when you’re done.

2. Outward Hound Invincibles Dog Toy

Outward Hound Invincibles dog toy is a multi-purpose squeaky toy. It’s double-seamed and double-lined for a longer life span.

There’s no stuffing, so you won’t have to worry about finding scraps of cotton scattered across your carpet. Instead, this toy comes with internal squeakers that satisfy your dog’s crunching needs and enhance playtime. It’s perfect for chewing, tugging, tossing, and cuddling. 

3. Arm and Hammer Super Treadz Chew Toy for Dogs

This all-natural rubber chew toy is made from durable materials for long-lasting playtime. It also contains grooves that help clean your dog’s teeth by stimulating their gums and removing plaque buildup.

Infused with baking soda, it freshens your dog’s breath safely and gently. The Super Treadz Chew comes in gator and gorilla varieties, and, as a bonus, it’s dishwasher-safe.

4. Chew King Supreme Fetch Balls

Furry tennis balls are no match for a repeat toy destroyer. But Chew King balls aren’t ordinary dog balls. They’re made of solid, natural rubber that’s durable, bouncy, and retains its shape. On top of being a dog ball perfect for a game of fetch, the hole in the middle can also be used to hide bite-sized treats. Best of all, Amazon reviewers report that they stand up to extreme chewers like Dobermans and Labradors.

There are two sizes to choose from, so even pint-sized heavy chewers can get in on the fun. This indestructible dog ball is also dishwasher safe so you can throw it in the wash to make it fresh again.

5. KONG Extreme Tire

You may be familiar with the KONG Classic dog toy, a favorite of pet owners. But what if your dog needs something even more heavy-duty? Look no further than the KONG Extreme Tire — the toughest toy in the KONG range. It’s made in the U.S. from durable rubber and is a good pick for medium to large dogs. And you can fill the inner wall with treats like peanut butter for extra playtime fun. 

6. WoofBite Indestructible Dog Disc

WoofBite created this indestructible frisbee for dogs with extra-sharp teeth that love to play catch and retrieve.

The brand says it uses a proprietary non-toxic rubber that makes this frisbee toy ultra-durable for aggressive chewers. And to back up that big talk, the brand even offers pet owners a lifetime guarantee. If your dog breaks it 10 years from now, they’ll offer a full refund or replacement.

7. Sugelary Squeaky Dog Toys

This pineapple-shaped squeaky chew toy is perfect for meeting your dog’s instinctual chewing needs and satisfying their boredom. It can be used for fetching, tug-of-war, or just some good old-fashioned chewing.

The Sugelary Squeaky durable rubber toy has been tested against German Shepherds, Mastiffs, Siberian Huskies, Labradors, Golden Retrievers, Pit Bulls, and other power chewers. It also comes complete with a squeaker, though Amazon reviewers say the squeaker isn’t as indestructible as the rest of the toy.

8. goDog Dragon

The goDog Dragon toy is made with special chew guard technology that’s proven to outlast standard dog plush toys.

It has a built-in squeaker, and the limbs dangle down, which creates an irresistible tug-toy opportunity. The most inviting thing about this toy is the soft bubble surface. Some “indestructible” plush dog toys are hard and a little too tough, which isn’t always what your dog is looking for.

Unfortunately, this plush squeaky toy may not be a match for Pit Bulls and other hardcore chewers.

9. Outward Hound Fire Biterz

The Outward Hound Fire Biterz toys are made from fire hose material. Outward Hound makes these plush toys from tightly woven rubber fibers and an extra-tough K9 Tuff guard lining.

This is made for play rather than just chewing, and it should last a lot longer than the average plush toy. It also includes the company’s signature Invincibles Squeakers. There’s no stuffing inside the toy, so if your dog does manage to rip it to shreds, there’s less mess to clean up.

10. Zikaton Dog Chew Toys for Indestructible Aggressive Chewers

This skeleton-shaped toy is ideal for any strong-jawed pup. The Zikaton Dog Chew Toy’s grooves and ridges will get between your dog’s teeth to clean out any plaque and tartar buildup. The rubber is non-toxic and dog-safe while maintaining an ideal balance between firmness and chewiness. 

It also has a milk flavor that will attract your dog to it and encourage chewing. The double-headed toy has a squeaker on each end, which will satisfy your dog’s instincts and encourage more play.

11. Apasiri Indestructible Dog Toy

The Apasiri indestructible dog toy is made of natural, durable rubber and food-grade nylon. It passed more than 1,000 bite tests against destructive chewers such as German Shepherds, Labradors, and other large breeds, so it should stand up to your pooch. 

Designed for medium to large-sized dogs, ‌this dog bone is tough, though some Amazon reviewers report that their large dogs were able to break off the ends of the bone.

The unique rubber spikes in the center of the toy provide cleaning for your dog’s teeth as they chew. This toy is also perfect for teething puppies. Plus, it’s beef-flavored, making it a yummy and enticing toy for your dog to safely enjoy.

An indestructible dog toy for every aggressive chewer

As your dog grows up, you’ll face a lot of challenges together. With a dog insurance policy, you can save on eligible vet bills for future accidents or illnesses.

In addition to vet care, some aggressive chewers will also need help from dog trainers. In the meantime, try one of the heavy-duty dog toys featured in this guide. Remember to read customer reviews before purchasing to make sure it’s suitable for your dog’s breed. In particular, Reddit can be a good source of information if you have questions about specific chew toys.

FAQs

---

---

---